Jonah Crab

Common Name Jonah Crab
Scientific name Cancer borealis

Sourcing Summary

Size

4-5 inches

Jonah crab are fished year-round, but landings tend to be slightly heavier in the fall. Flaky white Jonah crabmeat has a sweet taste and is available fresh year-round. Cooked Jonah crab comes in packs of leg, body, or combination meat and the whole claws sold separately. Jonah “snap-‘n-eats” are pre-cooked, pre-cracked crab claws. This crabmeat tends to be consistent because there are only a few processors for this fishery. The relatively large claws can be an affordable substitute for stone crab claws, with cooked Jonah ones selling for about half the price. Jonah crabmeat can be substituted or blended with more expensive crabmeat to make value-added seafood products such as crab cakes and stuffed flounder. Check the leg-to-body meat ratio periodically since that impacts the price of Jonah crab. Male Jonah crab from Canada tend to be about an inch larger (5") compared to those landed in the U.S. (4").

Jonah Crab Sustainability

Key sustainability sourcing notes for Jonah crab based on landings data from 2012-2016 and the most recent 2015 (Canada) and 2016 (U.S.) Seafood Watch assessments is as follows: 

  • ~95% of Jonah crab landings meet a Seafood Watch "Good Alternative (yellow)" rating (pot-caught from the U.S. Atlantic)
  • ~5% of Jonah crab landings meet a Seafood Watch "Avoid (red)" rating (pot-caught from Canadian Atlantic)
  • In June 2016, the rating for Jonah crab from the U.S. was upgraded from an "Avoid" to a "Good Alternative" because of the implementation of a fishery improvement project (FIP); this FIP is currently inactive
  • In July 2015, the rating for Jonah crab from Canada was downgraded from a "Good Alternative" to an "Avoid"
  • U.S. Jonah crab landings saw an increase of ~30% in 2016 compared to 2012 

 

Product Forms

Fresh/Frozen
Fresh
Product Forms
Cocktail Claws
Meat (cooked)
Whole Cooked
Fresh/Frozen
Frozen
Product Forms
Claw Meats
Cocktail Claws
Meat (cooked)
Whole

Fresh Seasonal Availability

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyes

Culinary Composition

Sweet

Flavor

Firm

Texture

High

Oil

Cooking Methods

Health/Nutrition

Nutrition facts

Serving Size: 100g
Amount per serving
Calories 99
Total Fat 1.9g
Cholesterol 76mg
Sodium 276mg
Carbohydrates 3.1g
Protein 16g

Biology

Jonah crabs have a round shell with small light spots, and claws with dark brown-black tips. The largest male reported had a carapace width of 22 cm; while females rarely exceed 15 cm. Jonah crabs reach maturity at larger sizes in more northern habitats, with males at 13 cm carapace width, and females at 9 cm. The species are known to move to areas of preferred temperature, in order to better regulate their body temperature. Their neural circuits compensate for temperature variations, as each phase that produces certain behaviors (such as walking or chewing) is temperature-independent. Females move offshore in the fall and winter and inshore in late spring and summer. Jonah crabs eat mainly blue mussels, as well as arthropods, snails, algae, and other mussels.

Species Habitat

Jonah crabs are found along the Atlantic coast of North America from Nova Scotia, Canada to the Dry Tortugas, Florida. They are generally found at depths of 164 to 984 feet (50 to 300 meters) and can even be found up to 2,625 feet (800 meters) deep. The life cycle of Jonah crab is poorly understood and little studied; however, what research there is has determined that their preferred habitat ranges from rocky substrates, with cover and crevices, in coastal and offshore areas to softer, silt and clay bottoms along the continental slope. While little is known about their movements and migration patterns, it is widely believed Jonah crab migrate in the spring to shallower waters and will return offshore to deeper, colder waters during the fall and winter. Most research has indicated the ideal temperature for Jonah crabs is between 46 and 54 degrees Fahrenheit (8 and 12 degrees Celsius).

Science & Management

Science

There is little scientific research or monitoring of bycatch in the Jonah crab fishery. A 2014 study done at the Department of Biology and Marine Science Center at Northeastern University looked at the thermoregulatory behavior of Jonah crab. They found that the crabs will self-regulate their body temperature and will adjust the direction and magnitude of their movements towards their preferred temperature range. The range is impacted by a previous acclimation to a certain temperature; however, the study found that, in all cases, the crabs prefer temperatures warmer than those they had been living in previously. Because of their sensitivity to temperature, Jonah crabs are often studied as a model species for warming ocean temperatures.

Management

The US Jonah crab fishery is managed by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) under the Interstate Fishery Management Plan (IFMP) for Jonah crab. Approved in 2015, and implemented in 2016, the IFMP was prompted by the American Lobster Board due to concerns regarding the recent and rapid increase of Jonah crab landings in the American lobster fishery. Historically, Jonah crabs have been considered a nuisance bycatch in the lobster fishery and used to supplement operational cost for these fishers. In recent years a directed fishery has emerged for both Jonah and rock crabs as abundance and market demand have increased. The majority of Jonah crabs are harvested by lobster fishers using lobster traps and occur in Massachusetts and Rhode Island.

The IFMP establishes a singular management unit for Jonah crab from Maine through Virginia – encompassing the entire Northwest Atlantic and adjacent inshore waters. The plan creates a uniform program for fishers and aims to promote conservation, reduce the possibility of recruitment failure, and allow full utilization of the resource. Among measures the IFMP establishes are:

  • A 4.75” minimum size limit
  • Restrictions prohibiting the take of egg-bearing females and partial claws
  • Trip limits
  • Gear restrictions (all traps must adhere to the Lobster Management Plan and have trap tag and escape vent requirements)
  • 100 percent harvester and dealer reporting
  • Limiting participation in the direct fishery to vessels and permit holders who already hold a lobster permit (or can prove participation in the crab fishery before June 2015)


The US Jonah crab fishery is not a federally regulated fishery and there have been no federal stock assessments conducted for the species. As no coast-wide stock assessment has been undertaken yet, there is no definition of overfishing for Jonah crab. While little information is available regarding the stock status of Jonah crab and the impact of the fishery, the ASMFC intends to develop a research strategy to gather this information and it is considered a high priority for the future. 

The ASMFC and American Lobster Management Board are generally responsible for carrying out all activities under the IFMP with the Management Board establishing and overseeing the activities of the following:

  • A Jonah Crab Advisory Panel that will meet annually (or as necessary) to review management changes and developments in the fishery;
  • A Jonah Crab Technical Committee that will review stock assessment development once that information is available and will forward recommendations to the Management Board;
  • A Jonah Crab Stock Assessment Subcommittee that will meet every five years to review and update or preform a benchmark stock assessment for Jonah crab; and,
  • A Jonah Crab Plan Review Team that will review implementation of the management program annually and will work to prioritize future research needs. 

The American Lobster Management Board is also responsible for reviewing state compliance with the IFMP.

The Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) Canada manages the Canadian Jonah crab fishery. Jonah crabs have traditionally been caught as bycatch in the Canadian inshore and offshore lobster fisheries; however, in the 1990s exploratory fisheries emerged as market demand for Jonah crab grew in Canada. In 2000 a permanent fishery was established and in 2004 all exploratory crab permits became permanent commercial licenses. As of 2010, there has been little to no commercial activity in the Maritimes (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island) due to a decline in abundance and therefore low catch rates as well as low market demand and price. The offshore Jonah crab fishery is inactive and most landings in that region are from the bycatch and bait fisheries for lobster. 

Conservation Criteria - Wild

Impact on Stock

These crabs are usually found in the western North Atlantic, with the primary source in the United States and have medium abundance since there is very little biological data available on them. Segregation by sex and size could make the crab vulnerable to fishing pressure, while the fecundity is on the higher side. The crab is susceptible to environmental variables, so its population varies.

 

Habitat impacts (Wild)

Most Jonah crabs are caught with pots and traps intended to catch lobster, which have relatively little impact on the marine habitat. The areas where the crab is caught vary, with some being more sensitive and others more resilient to interactions with pots.

Bycatch

Jonah crab were once an annoying bycatch in the lobster fishery because they stole the bait, but now the crab have become a valuable commercial catch on their own. Critically endangered North Atlantic right whales sometimes get entangled in the lines connecting traps or pots together, making that a continuing environmental concern for the Jonah crab fishery.

Management effectiveness

Individual states manage the fishery in the U.S. while the Canadian government manages them in that country. Measures in both regions include minimum size limits; sex restrictions so that no females can be caught, seasonal closures, limited entry access, and bycatch provisions. However, since the Jonah crab fishery only emerged relatively recently, little scientific assessment has been done on it and there are currently no quotas.

Conservation Criteria - Farmed

Origin Method Ratings
All Other Origins All Other Fishing Methods  
Canada - Atlantic Pot/Trap  
USA - Atlantic Pot/Trap  
Name Country State / Province
Albion Farms & Fisheries Canada British Columbia
Atlantic Red Crab Company United States Massachusetts
John Nagle Co. United States Massachusetts
Lusamerica Foods, Inc. United States California
Pacific Harvest Seafoods United States California
Profish Ltd. United States District of Columbia
Sammy's Seafood Inc United States Florida
Santa Monica Seafood, Inc. United States California
Sea to Table, USA United States New York
The Lobster Place Wholesale Seafood United States New York